Striking, austere visuals and star casting can’t bring heart to this cold and incoherent take on Shakespeare’s story of magic, legacy and forgiveness.
Bringing Shakespeare back to the Theatre Royal Drury Lane for the first time since John Gielgud played Prospero there in 1957 – and famously predicted that thereafter, the venue would be “lost to musicals” – this sombre Tempest is alienating and coldly aloof.
Relentlessly audacious director Jamie Lloyd deploys many of his signature techniques. There’s big-name casting – with Sigourney Weaver making her West End debut as Prospero. There’s also stark, stripped-back aesthetics, and a terse, unfussy minimalism to the performers’ delivery that builds an effectively eerie atmosphere, but leaves Shakespeare’s poetry feeling underserved, its meaning adrift.
Soutra Gilmour’s bold design sets the action in a bleak, blackened wasteland, where shreds of white smoke crawl across an undulating landscape of glimmering volcanic sand. Vast sections of silk ripple overhead, sometimes in narrow ribbons evoking distant ocean horizons, sometimes bowing and billowing out towards the audience like full sails or lowering storm clouds. The costumes, also by Gilmour, are similarly striking, but less coherent, decking out the wreck’s survivors in greatcoats and scarves of slate grey and icy blue, while the islanders’ attire gestures towards dark burlesque, with black leathers, corsetry, and chainmail.
Continues…
Jon Clark’s lush, tactile lighting establishes a fluid, subaqueous gloom, then pierces it with precise streaks of cold silver and warm copper light, beams intersecting to discover characters striking heroic poses, or freeze them in moments of magically induced seizure.
At the centre of this shifting world, Weaver’s Prospero is a faint, melancholy presence, her delivery flat and frequently tentative. Pensive and watchful, she remains seated on stage throughout, observing the characters she has caught in her magical machinations, responding to their follies and underhand plots with unexpected compassion. There is never a sense that Weaver’s Prospero sincerely seeks revenge on the nobles who wronged her. Instead, the dispossessed Duke seems motivated by a keen sense of her own mortality, intending only to restore her family name and arrange a suitable marriage for her daughter with the time she has left.
Mara Huf gives Miranda a sour, snarky energy, clashing with Prospero with all the built-up antagonism you would expect from a teenager trapped on a deserted island with their overbearing mother. But she shares some warm chemistry with James Phoon’s Ferdinand – played here as an appealing, uncomplicated jock with a nice line in physical comedy.
But it’s Mason Alexander Park’s equally unsettling and beguiling Ariel who makes the strongest impression. Descending menacingly from above on ropes or stalking the black dunes wrapped in billowing silks, they growl, roar, and hiss their lines with an electrifying feral intensity, then break into gorgeously delicate song, driving home the unearthly strangeness that permeates Prospero’s island, and this production as a whole.
Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £7.99