Fraught comedy-drama that sidesteps any in-depth emotional soul-searching
This complicated comedy-drama from Buddy Thomas was a minor hit Off-Broadway in 2000, staring Sex and the City’s Mario Cantone. There have been several UK revivals over the past decade and this new production, directed by Helen Bang, was scheduled to take place at the recently shuttered Stage Door in the West End. Undeterred, the producers moved the production to Waterloo East.
It’s set in a messy apartment in Staten Island in the lead-up to Christmas. Terry is a bitter, out-of-work actor, just about making ends meet serving up greasy food in a mafia-owned diner. He can’t find a boyfriend, so he spends much of his free time knocking back cheap vodka and marshalling a deeply awkward love triangle between his flatmate Sam, her boyfriend Alex and their mutual friend Buck. While Sam is away on tour, Alex and Buck begin an affair that only serves to amplify Terry’s loneliness. On the isolated occasion when Terry does manage to hook up – with a guy he meets on the ferry – he turns out to be a married man just looking for sex.
Continues...
Thomas’ fast-paced comedy is quite bleak, not least because it never slows down to explore any of its complex emotional make-up. Bad things just keep happening. It’s like dropping into a long-running sitcom, when you don’t know any of the characters and don’t quite understand their extreme behaviour. Bang’s production hits the ground running and pitched at a high level, and has nowhere to go after that. Manic behaviour gives way to hysteria, fuelled by vodka and nervous energy. There’s only a brief moment near the end of the play in which an exchange between Terry and Sam gives meaning to the curious title and offers something like thoughtful conversation.
The centre of this fractious piece is Terry, and James Grimm attacks the role with such nervous energy that it’s a little disconcerting. It’s a performance that does suggest a sense of self-loathing and despair: Terry lashes out cruelly at almost everything but refuses to take advice from others. To some extent, even Nicholas Gauci’s bullish hook-up Roger offers some sort of opportunistic release, but Terry is too tightly wound to settle for casual sex, despite instigating it himself.
The love triangle between Jonny Davidson’s conflicted Alex, Sinéad Donnelly’s pragmatic Sam and James Mackay as straight-talking Buck is barely explored, but Bang amps up the energy to mitigate that issue. The play is a little dated, although there are still laughs to be had at some of Terry’s frank observations. Mostly, though, it’s pretty dark, with just Bang’s zippy direction, which occasionally verges on farce, to provide the laughs.
Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £7.99