Broadway & International

Training & Drama Schools

Backstage & Technical

Opera

Dance

West End

Musical Theatre

Pantomime

Edinburgh Fringe

Obituaries & Archive

NPO 2023-26

Awards

Jobs & Auditions

Hot Topics

Acting & Performance

Shakespeare

The Lord of the Rings review

“Precious moments of magic”

ReviewsAug 2, 2023by Dave FargnoliWatermill Theatre, Newbury

Georgia Louise in The Lord of the Rings at Watermill Theatre, Newbury. Photo: Pamela Raith

Gorgeous aesthetics and a lively staging lift this flawed fantasy-musical revival by Shaun McKenna and Matthew Warchus

Support The Stage by registering or subscribing

To continue reading this article you must be logged in.

Register or login below to unlock 3 free articles every month.

OR

Or subscribe today and get unlimited access to thestage.co.uk.

Dave Fargnoli

More from this Author

The Glorious French Revolution review

The Red Shoes review

Going for Gold review

Here & Now review

Reviews by Matthew HemleyAlexandra Theatre, Birmingham

Wicked review

Reviews by Tim BanoCinemas

Steps musical Here & Now to tour the UK

Production News by Matthew Hemley

The Glorious French Revolution review

Reviews by Dave FargnoliNew Diorama Theatre, London

Here & Now review

Alexandra Theatre, Birmingham

Wicked review

Cinemas

The Glorious French Revolution review

New Diorama Theatre, London

[title of show] review

Southwark Playhouse, London

Aspects of Love review

Lyric Theatre, London

King Lear review

Wyndham's Theatre, London

Staged

BBC One

Sunset Boulevard review

Savoy Theatre, London

Recommended for you

Here & Now review

Reviews by Matthew HemleyAlexandra Theatre, Birmingham

Wicked review

Reviews by Tim BanoCinemas

Steps musical Here & Now to tour the UK

Production News by Matthew Hemley

The Glorious French Revolution review

Reviews by Dave FargnoliNew Diorama Theatre, London

Dave Fargnoli

Dave is a playwright and critic. He was the winner of The Stage's Critic Search 2015

More from this author

The Glorious French Revolution review

The Red Shoes review

Going for Gold review

Reviews

Latest
Most Read

Here & Now review

Wicked review

The Glorious French Revolution review

[title of show] review

Shit. Meet. Fan. review

The Elixir of Love review

Wicked review

The Red Shoes review

Royal Ballet: Maddaddam review

The Tales of Hoffmann review

Here & Now review

Wolves on Road review

Jobs

Deputy Technical Manager (So...

City: London Salary: £33,144 - £...

Apply

Technical Instructor (Stage ...

City: London Salary: £29,758 - £...

Apply

Summer Theatre Jobs in America

City: New York Salary: SALARY + FR...

Apply

Deputy Head of Electrics

City: London Salary: SOLT/BECTU ...

Apply

Theatre Technician

City: Winchester Salary: £23,409 - £...

Apply

Potters Theatre Company - Le...

City: Hopton Salary: Competitive

Apply

Technical Manager 1.0 FTE

City: London Salary: £38,071 - £...

Apply

Redcoat Auditions

City: Various Salary: Competitive

Apply

Marketing Manager

City: Blackpool Salary: £30,000 per...

Apply

Head of Stage

City: London Salary: SOLT/BECTU ...

Apply

Head of Musical Theatre (Lea...

City: Dubai Salary: 20,000 AED ...

Apply

Sound No 1

City: London Salary: Salary base...

Apply

Entertainer at Five Lakes

City: Maldon, Essex Salary: Competitive

Apply

Costume Cutter

City: Leeds Salary: £25,685 per...

Apply

Technical Director

City: Chichester Salary: £60-£70,000...

Apply

More about this organisation

The top 12 shows to see this autumn

Opinion by The Stage

Watermill, National and Wilton’s Music Hall benefit from Andrew Lloyd Webber Foundation grants

News by Georgia Snow

In pictures (August 2): Lenny Henry, Lily James, Park Theatre, Hope Mill, New Vic, Leicester Square Theatre

Features by The Stage

In pictures (May 17): Park, York Theatre Royal, Korean Dance festival, National Youth Theatre, Lenny Henry at Royal Birmingham Conservatoire

Features by The Stage

More Reviews

Here & Now review

Alexandra Theatre, Birmingham

Wicked review

Cinemas

The Glorious French Revolution review

New Diorama Theatre, London

[title of show] review

Southwark Playhouse, London

Recommended for you

Here & Now review

Reviews by Matthew HemleyAlexandra Theatre, Birmingham

Wicked review

Reviews by Tim BanoCinemas

Steps musical Here & Now to tour the UK

Production News by Matthew Hemley

The Glorious French Revolution review

Reviews by Dave FargnoliNew Diorama Theatre, London

Nicola Walker and Stephen Mangan to star in new Mike Bartlett play

Wicked review

The Red Shoes review

Anonymous letter warns former Actors’ Benevolent Fund trustees to ‘be afraid’

‘Slap in the face’: backlash against National's primary school tours cut

Producer Jamie Wilson reveals plan to run a regional theatre

Royal Ballet: Maddaddam review

The National Theatre’s cut to its school touring scheme is damaging to theatre – and children

Birmingham Rep names Joe Murphy new artistic director

London theatres to dim lights for Timothy West

Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue

Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £5.99

SUBSCRIBE

Newspaper

More

Subscribe

Start a subscription today from just £7.99 Subscribe

The Lord of the Rings review

Support The Stage by registering or subscribing

More from this Author

More on this topic

More Reviews

Recommended for you

More from this author

Reviews

More about this organisation

More Reviews

Recommended for you

Most Read

Your subscription helps ensure our journalism can continue

Newspaper

More

Info

Awards

Legal

Digital