Tender performances animate this dramatically inert comedy about queer love in later life
While walking his dog on Hampstead Heath, irrepressible pensioner Percy strikes up a conversation with lonely widower and fellow dog owner Frank. From that first, awkward conversation, they build a tentative friendship that blossoms into a deeply meaningful romance for both men.
Like the unhurried relationship at the story’s heart, this sweet-natured odd couple comedy – directed by Sean Mathias and featuring warm performances from Roger Allam and Ian McKellen – takes a long time to get going. Focused entirely on sketching out his characters, playwright Ben Weatherill studiously avoids moments of drama. In the first act, we inexplicably skip over the first significant escalation in the two men’s burgeoning relationship. In the second, the couple almost has an argument over a serious difference of opinion, but they ultimately agree to disagree.
Weatherill’s meandering script has some nice moments of humour – though too many punchlines involve fat-shaming Frank’s dog. There are plenty of promising themes here too, though none are explored sufficiently. When controversial academic Percy writes a book proposing radical responses to the climate crisis, he is publicly vilified, and his speaking arrangements are abruptly cancelled. Later scenes touch on the overstretched state of the NHS; the two men wait hours for an ambulance and one receives a late diagnosis due to a misplaced biopsy.
Continues...
Allam and McKellen are wonderfully watchable, sharing an easy, believable chemistry and wringing laughs and bittersweet emotion from the intentionally mundane dialogue. McKellen’s witty, intellectual Percy is by turns dry and charming, prickly and tender, but prone to lashing out when he feels he’s losing control. When his health begins to fail, he crumples, becoming doddery and distracted, almost childlike in his fragility. Allam’s Frank is the more reserved of the two, but also the more compassionate. Holding his emotions tightly in check at first, he opens up gradually, and by the end of the play is wearing his heart on his sleeve, freed from either shame or need. Allam makes the journey feel clear and completely plausible.
Mathias keeps the slowly paced production on just the right side of sentimentality. Poignant moments are balanced by a handful of fun set pieces – a karaoke sequence is pulled off with particular flair – and the whole production is suffused with a mood of elegiac hopefulness.
Morgan Large’s pretty set features a circular, multilevel deck of wooden beams. Understated use of a revolve sees a number of wooden plinths slickly realigned into new configurations to suggest various indoor and outdoor locations, while the rear wall splits open to create a window on to a visually striking still image of lush green woodland where Frank and Percy’s dogs run and play together, always just out of sight.
Invest in The Stage today with a subscription starting at just £7.99